My neighbors have a Meyer lemon tree that produced hundreds of lemons a couple of years ago. I think I zested and juiced about 175 lemons that year!
I also developed several fun recipes as a result. I still have a little more juice and zest in my freezer from last year’s harvest. My neighbors just called and told me that the lemons from this year’s crop are now ready- yay! It’s not a big harvest like it was that one year, but I am grateful to get any Meyers lemons that I can!
If you have not had Meyers lemons before, they are a cross between lemon and orange. Their juice and skin are much milder and less tart than a traditional lemon. If you can find the fruit in a grocery store, the price per pound seems expensive but if you break that down to a per fruit price it isn’t that bad.
This cookie recipe (and any of my other Meyer lemon recipes) will work fine with “regular” lemons. You will want to use less rind and juice from a regular lemon because it is so much more acidic. You will probably also want to add more sugar- you will need to taste and see.
You can also make this recipe using “regular” flour if you do not have an issue with gluten.
These cookies are thin and very lemony tasting. If you use the dough immediately after you make it, the cookies will be thin and chewy. If you refrigerate the dough for 1- 1/2 to 2 hours, the cookies will be a little thicker and more crunchy like a “regular” cookie. Don’t refrigerate this dough more than a couple of hours because it will dry out and change so that is not as nice.
If you love Meyer Lemons, I posted a recipe for Meyer Lemon Pancakes.
I also have a Meyer Lemon Mousse recipe that I will be posting.
I also make an incredible Lemon Meringue Pie, but I want to work on my crust a little more and make it prettier.
Other lemon recipes that I am thinking about are Lemon Pudding Cake (I just need to make my recipe one more time to make sure it is perfect), Lemon Tea Bread, Lemon Curd Thumbprint Cookie.
You would never guess that I love lemon would you?
If your local store does not carry Meyer lemons, a wonderful online source for Organic Meyer lemons is Birch-Hill Organics in California. They were nice enough to donate a box of their Meyer lemons for my giveaway that just ended January 31st. The smallest box that they sell is 7 pounds of lemons for $45, but that includes shipping. The Meyer lemons that I just worked with here in Arizona averaged about 5 per pound, so if the lemons from Birch-Hill are the same size you will get about 35 lemons. If that is more than you can use (you can always freeze the zest and juice like I do), you could go in with a friend or two on a box. You will love them when you try them!
I shared this recipe with Homemaker Monday at 11th Heaven’s Homemaking Haven, Tuesdays At The Table at All Of The Small Stuff, Tasty Tuesdays at 33 Shades Of Green, Hearth And Soul Hop at A Moderate Life, Tasty Tuesday at Who Is Laura, Gluten Free Wednesdays at The Gluten Free Homemaker, Real Food Wednesday at Kelly The Kitchen Kop, Real Food Weekly at The Whole Gang, Full Plate Thursdays at Miz Helen’s Country Cottage, Frugal Food Thursday at Frugal Follies, Sweets For A Saturday at Sweet As Sugar Cookies, Friday Favorites at Simply Sweet Home.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Blend dry ingredients in medium bowl and set aside:
1 cup GF Flour Mix *
3/8 teaspoon salt
3/8 teaspoon baking soda
Cream the following ingredients together in a large bowl:
6 Tblsp unsalted butter, softened slightly
1 Tblsp rice milk or water
1/4 cup Meyer lemon juice (less if using a “regular” lemon)
1 Tblsp Meyer lemon rind (less if using a “regular” lemon)
I use a Microplane zester so that the pieces of rind are very fine.
1/2 cup sugar (maybe a little more if using “regular” lemon- taste mixture to tell)
1 teaspoon vanilla
Add flour mixture to butter mixture and stir until thoroughly blended.
Dough will be very moist.
Line 2 cookie sheets with parchment paper.
Drop approximately 1 Tblsp of dough per cookie, 12 cookies per sheet.
I use my fingers to form the dough into a rounder shape before baking.
Bake a total of 10-11 minutes, switching cookie sheets from top to bottom after 5 minutes of baking. You should see just a little bit of light brown color around the edge of the cookies.
Wait until the cookies have cooled before removing from the parchment- they are very soft and crumbly until then!
Makes about 24 cookies.
*GF Flour Mixture
The GF flour mixture that I use is pretty standard. I use Authentic Foods gluten free flours because they are ground more finely than commercial brand GF flours that you can buy off the shelf. This results in wonderful baked goods that do not have that “gritty” feel when you chew them like so many products that we all tried in the beginning!
GF Flour Mixture
2 cups AF Superfine Brown Rice Flour (available in the amazon.com store on my blog)
2/3 cup AF Potato Starch Flour (available in my store)
1/3 cup AF Tapioca Flour (available in my store)
I make up several batches of this mixture at a time and keep it in a canister. I keep all of my other GF flours in the freezer.
Welcome to Andreas Kitchen! If you are new here, you might want to subscribe to my blog to get updated whenever I post a recipe.






Yummy Andrea! These look fabulous. I’ve just got to try them!
This looks so plain but I guess it really taste nice. I should try this one and add some cream cheese frostings or some dulce de leche toppings.
Hi Rose- thanks for your comment! I tend to go with more simple and less sugary flavors in my desserts but you could probably take these cookies over the top with a light lemony frosting. I think if you go with too heavy of a flavor in the frosting it would overpower the lemon cookie flavor itself.
This sounds great. I think I can add a little bit of chocolate syrup on the top to add some flavor.
I love lemon! These cookies look delicious!
I’m having the very first GIVEAWAY on my blog. Please stop by to submit an entry. Best of luck!
http://utry.it/2011/01/happy-birthday-to-meand-very-first.html
I love lemon desserts. I usually make lemon cake, so I will have to try lemon cookies.
Thanks for your comment Amy! Good luck with your giveaway!
Oh my goodness…these sound awesome! I call the Meyer Lemon the “elusive” one…because I’ve never seen one! I guess I better head off to enter your giveaway. Thank you for sharing this w/ the hearth and soul hop this week!
This looks great. I love that it is the peak of citrus season. Yum
These look great. I should make them as a treat for my husband this weekend.
These look so good! I love anything lemon. I’ve never had Meyer lemons before. In fact, I have never even seen them in the supermarkets that I shopped in Louisiana. The produce selection seems better in New England. Weird but true. I’m going to look for these. Thanks! Candace
I love anything with lemon .. lemon cake .. lemon bread .. lemon rice
Have to try this cookies but first I have to figure out how to find out Meyer lemon
Hi Andrea,
I have several of these Meyer Lemon Cookies on my plate and I can’t wait to try them. I am so happy that you brought them to Full Plate Thursday. Thank you so much for coming today and please come back!
Thanks for your comment Candace! Meyer lemons are well worth searching for if you love lemon!
Hi Linda! They really are good! Now I am thinking about trying the recipe with other types of citrus- yum!
Thank you Miz Helen! It is my pleasure to participate in your Full Plate Thursday!
I have a fabulous recipe for lemon curd that I make with my Meyer lemons. If you would like to have it email me!
Thank you Peg! I emailed you for the recipe!
I have made these twice in 2 days… and they are yummy beyond words. I added some finely chopped walnuts and dried blueberries to them. Also, since I LOVE the taste of lemon, I peeled and finely minced the rind instead of zesting. Real intense lemon flavor. Thanks so much for sharing this recipe…need to go and make another batch!
Thank you so much for your nice comments Karmala! Here is a link to one of my posts that lists a whole bunch of other lemon recipes from across the Internet. You might find more things to try! http://www.andreaskitchen.net/2011/01/giveaway-organic-meyer-lemons/
Success! I am delighted to report that the Meyers lemon cookies I made using your wonderful recipe was successful. Big time. I can’t believe how easy it was, especially considering it was my first try.
Every year when the Meyer lemon season gets underway I host a potluck dinner where everyone is asked to bring a Meyer lemon dish, from entrees to desserts. Everything has to have Meyer lemons in it. I can’t wait to show off your Meyers lemons cookies. I just know it will be a big hit.
Christine
Thank you for your great comments Christine! I am so glad that you liked the cookies!
my mother used to make a lemon sponge pie that was to die for. many years of trying just brought me close to her flavor. now I have my own Meyer lemon tree and can make her pie and she didn’t even know what a Meyer lemon was! I freeze the juice and the rind but am never sure how much of each to use when the recipe calls for “juice and rind of one lemon”. Any suggestions?
Hi Linda, I hate when recipes don’t give precise measurements (it is the Virgo in me- I measure everything!) I think I would start with a tablespoon of the rind, which is quite a bit for any recipe and maybe 3 tablespoons of juice. Your taste will dictate whether you should add more after that. I have so many recipes that I have gathered, usually several for any dish that I think of making so glancing at those gives me a better idea of accurate quantities before I create my own version of the recipe. Of course if you are using Meyers lemons you can use more of the juice and rind since it is not as tart and acidic. Thanks for your question!
Lemon cookies, sounds good to me.
Can you please tell me when the season is good to order some, as I live in new york state and these supermarkets do not know what meyer lemons are!
Thank You
Hi Ann Marie, Meyer lemons are generally available in the winter. I always see thm in my store at least by December. It seemed like they were available for quite a few months after that this year too.
I tried making this, but when I put the dough in the oven it melted and became super runny!
I used half a cup of cornstarch and half a cup of brown rice flower, and brown sugar.. I have no idea what went wrong
Hi Julieta,
Sorry you had a problem with this cookie recipe. It has a lot of butter in it so it bakes the best when the dough is as cold as possible from the refrigerator.
Hope that helps!